next up previous
Next: Introduction Up: Heron Island Proceedings: Mould

Do we know the velocity field well enough to determine H ?

Jeremy Mould

MSSSO, Institute of Advanced Studies, ANU

Abstract:

In a provocative paper Turner and colleagues have questioned whether the classical approach to the extragalactic distance scale is capable of measuring a global value of H in the presence of a velocity field which exhibits large scale flows. The results of their numerical experiments can be summed up in the following alarming illustration: ``Even if the local expansion rate is known to be 80 8 km/s/Mpc out to 30 h Mpc in the North Galactic Cap, the 95% confidence limits on the true global value of H is 50--128 km/sec/Mpc in a CDM model."

The Hubble Space Telescope Key Project to measure H effects the calibration of secondary distance indicators whose effective range extends beyond the Coma cluster. At Coma the same rms difference has fallen from 45% to 3% in CDM according to Turner's model.

Empirical evidence that real velocity fields present no larger problem than these calculations suggest is provided by:

(1) an all-sky survey of Tully-Fisher distances to clusters of galaxies

(2) an all-sky survey of brightest cluster galaxies (Lauer & Postman)

(3) the type II supernova expanding photospheres data set.

We can hypothesize a `bubble model' in which 0.5, that is, H = 75 km/s/Mpc within the distance of the Coma cluster and H = 50 outside that radius. The data appear to rule out a model with such a large difference between local and global H.

Such a model is also heavily constrained by the isotropy of the cosmic microwave background on 1 scales. One hundred Mpc, which is approximately the radius of the volume enclosing Coma, corresponds to 1 (12) on the surface of last scattering for = 1 (0.2). The requirement that 0.5 in a `bubble model' of this type implies a three times larger density perturbation than is represented by the Great Attractor. A Great Attractor would evolve from = 1.7 in an = 1 Universe. The measured 1 on 1.5 scales. A low density Universe would relax these constraints considerably.





next up previous
Next: Introduction Up: Heron Island Proceedings: Mould



Heron Island Conference
Tue Aug 15 22:04:57 EST 1995